Welcome to Cookie Tray
Making the Edible incredible One Bite
at a Time
Honoring Our First Responders
In March, it will be one year since First Responders started working endless days and nights for us. Let's honor these men and women during the month of March with our Good Vibes and Chocolate Chip Cookies. Order a batch of these cookies and we will deliver them to a local New York hospital.
Keep your cookie jar filled with our cookies
Freshly Baked Goodness You Can’t Resist. Stock up on a some cookies today.
Cookie Decorating Kits
Looking for fun in a box?
Each cookie kit contains sugar cookies, an icing bag and decorations. See our complete line of cookie kits
Whether you need to satisfy a craving or feed a crowd, we’ve got you covered. Our delicious and freshly prepared products are sure to satisfy everyone. Check out what we have to offer below and place your order today!
From chocolate to vanilla to stuffed cupcakes, they are the perfect dessert when you want just a few bites of cake
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I place my order?
Please go to the Contact tab above to message us about what you would like to order. We will get back to you as soon as possible.
When should I place my order?
It is suggested that you place your order for sweet treats approximately two weeks before your special occasion. Please contact us if it is inside of two weeks.
Do we sell gluten free treats?
We are not a gluten free bakery, but we do offer gluten free treats. Although we try our best to minimize cross contamination, we cannot guarantee it 100%.
Do we ship our sweet treats?
Yes, we ship within the continental United States. Please contact us to get further details and costs.
Follow us on Instagram @cookietray